NINE IMP SWING GOES AGAINST JEC ON A PART SCORE (HCP ARE EVEN DIVIDED) DEAL WITH NO SIGNIFICANT DISTRIBUTIONAL FEATURES. CAN'T EVERYBODY PLAY A PART SHORE CONTRACT ON HANDS SUCH AS THESE?
| #1 9 8 4 D: N J T 6 3 V: NONE 9 2 A K T 3 A 7 J 6 5 2 A Q 5 4 2 K 9 K J 6 4 Q T 8 3 9 8 7 6 5 K Q T 3 8 7 A 7 5 Q J 4 2 | @ JEC'S TABLE W N E S - P P 1C 1H 1N P P 2D P P P NORTH HAS A CHOICE BETWEEN 1NT, WHICH, AFTER THEY OVERCALL, HAS A HIGHER LOWER LIMIT – 8-10 HCP, LEAVE THOSE 6'S AND RAT 7'S ALONE AND PASS THEM. THE PROBLEM WITH A TWO CLUB RAISE IS THAT N-S WILL NEVER PLAY TWO CLUBS, ONCE HAVING SHOWN THEIR FIT (THE LAW SAYS – WHEN THEY HAVE A FIT AT THE TWO LEVEL, WE HAVE A FIT AT THE TWO LEVEL AND WE DON'T WANT THEM TO PLAY IN TWO OF THEIR SUIT). BUT THEIR EXPERIENCED WEST PLAYER WAS AWARE THAT AN AUCTION THAT STARTS 1C – X – 1NT GUARANTEES A CLUB FIT, AND SO CONFIDENTLY AND BOLDLY REBID 2D. @ THEIR TABLE - P P 1C 1H 2C X P 3D P 3H P 4H X P P P |
9 IMP SWING TO OPPS WHEN JEC'S EAST PLAYER TORTURES PARTNER INTO A 5-2 FIT AFTER HAVING UNCOVERED A 4-4 BUT THEIR WEST SHOULD KNOW BETTER BECAUSE WITH 10 HCP AND THREE CARD HEART SUPPORT, EAST CAN CUE BID 3C, SO, HAVING FAILED TO CUE 3C, EAST DENIES A HAND WITH BOTH 10+ HCP AND THREE OR MORE HEARTS – SO, MAYBE WEST HAS 10 HCP WITH TWO HEARTS, A NICE JUICY HEART DOUBLETON K-J? THAT'S SURE WHAT IT SOUNDS LIKE TO ME. IT'S ONE THING TO KNOW WHAT YOUR HAND IS. IT'S SOMETIMES QUITE ANOTHER TO CURB YOUR ENTHUSIASM TO LET PARTNER IN ON THE DEAL. | X IS A FINE CALL 3H IS NOT, EAST NEEDS TO LEARN TO PASS, TO COMPLETE THE DESCRIPTION OF A MINIMUM ADVANCING HAND WITH 4-CARD DIAMOND SUPPORT. WHEN YOU CONTINUE SERENDIPITOUSY BIDDING ON THESE CONTESTED AUCTIONS (REMEMBER, E-W HAD WON THE BID IN 3D) YOU SHOW EITHER BETTER POINTS, BETTER SHAPE, OR BOTH. |
IN A RARE DEFENSIVE LAPSE, JEC LETS 3NT MAKE – BEST DEFENSE IS TO CASH ONLY TWO SPADE WINNERS RATHER THAN ESTABLISH THE NINTH TRICK, A SPADE, FOR WEST. MUST EXIT A CLUB OR HEART AT TRICK 3. MOST ILLUMINATING AUCTION REVEALS THE KILLING OPENING LEAD AND KILLING LINE OF DEFENSE (TRUMP LEAD) AGAINST FIVE CLUBS.
WITH 14 HCP OPPOSITE 6, AND ONLY A QUASI FIT, DO YOU REALLY WANT TO DECLARER FIVE CLUBS ON A 6-3 OR 3NT? WITH A 6-4 CLUB FIT, 5 CLUBS IS AN EXCELLENT CONTRACT. YOU NEED LOTS OF TRUMP TO PLAY AT THE FIVE LEVEL WHEN THE POINTS ARE EVENLY SPLIT. WOULD BE MUCH BETTER. ACTUALLY, THE BAD LUCK WAS HEARTS GOING 5-1.
| #8 Q 8 D: W J 9 7 4 2 V: NONE J 9 2 7 6 2 J 6 4 2 T 7 5 A K 8 6 3 K T 8 7 6 - - Q J 4 A K 10 8 5 3 A K 8 5 3 Q T A Q 5 4 3 9 | @ JEC'S TABLE W N E S P P 1C 1S P(1) P 2H(2) 3D(3) X(4) P 3H(5) P 5C(6) P P P @ THEIR TABLE P P 1C 1S P(1) P 2H(2) P(3) 2N(4) P 3H(5) P 3N(6) P P(7) P |
(1) WEST IS NOT EVEN REMOTELY TEMPTED TO CALL 1NT HERE – NOT ENOUGH POINTS (8-10) ARE NEEDED AFTER A ONE-LEVEL OVERCALL), NO SPADE STOPPER, SINGLETON IN OVERCALL'S SUIT ARE HORRIBLE (2) REVERSING INTO 2H, MAKES IT IMPOSSIBLE FOR E-2 TO EVER RETURN TO 2C, MEANS EAST HAS A STRONG HAND 17+ PLAYING POINTS, (AT LEAST) FOUR HEARTS, AND LONGER CLUBS: IT IS NOT ENTIRELY FORCING HERE, BECAUSE THE WEST HAND IS LIMITED BY THE INITIAL PASS (3) MY OWN THOUGHT IS THAT SOUTH HAS SOME KIND OF DEATH WISH – THIS IS NOT A FIT AUCTION AND HE COMES SALLYING IN, JUST LOOKING TO GO OFF 800 ON A PART SCORE DEAL. (4) WEST DREAMS OF PICKING UP 800 (5) EAST SAYS, OH, NO, YOU DON'T KNOW I'M 6-5, ONLY THAT I HAVE 4 (OR MORE HEARTS) LONGER CLUBS, AND A STRONG HAND – WHICH I HAVE PREVIOUSLY DESCRIBED THAT WEST WANTED TO DEFEND DIAMONDS ON – SOME SHAPES ARE NOT MEANT TO BE SHOWN. (6) TRYING TO GET BACK 400. SADLY, THE BIDDING PAINTS A PICTURE TO THE WINNING LEAD, THE CLUB, AND 5C CANNOT MAKE | (1) , (2) IBID (3) GOOD DISCIPLINED PASS ON THIS MISTFIT AUCTION. THE STRENGTH OF SOME HANDS IS NEVER MEANT TO BE SHOWN. (4) SHOWS SOME VALUES SINCE THE INITIAL PASS HAS A MAXIMUM UPPER LIMIT. (5) IBID (6) BECAUSE THIS HAND HAS LIKELY ONLY 2 TRICKS (TWO HEART RUFFS, ON THE BIDDING-INDICATED CLUB LEAD) AND SINCE THE SPADE STOPPER DOES NOT EXIST, I LIKE FOUR CLUBS BETTER. (7) OKAY, I'VE SHOWN MY HAND – IT'S STRENGTH (WHICH IS QUITE DISTRIBUTIONAL, WITH ONLY 14 VERY SOLID HCP – NONETHELESS WORTH THE AUCTION) AND IT'S SHAPE. I TRUST YOU PARTNER! |